Comics for Kids

Toon Books has recently come out with its latest in the Benny and Penny series.  I was initially not in love with Benny and Penny.  While they’ve won me over, they still aren’t my favorite titles in this series.  That honor belongs to Eleanor Davis’s Stinky, a book that is nearly perfect in my mind.  They’ve also just issued another new one called Zig and Wikki, which is a about science and at a slightly higher reading level.  I already touted it to all my homeschool friends, but Toon Books has an amazing website with lesson plans, a way to use the characters to make your own comic panels and an online reader that will read the books aloud in multiple languages, including Chinese.  No, really, genuine 中文! 真的!

I enjoy comics myself and my kids seem drawn to them in a way that they aren’t to other books.  With the way that they integrate visual cues and written language, they seem like the perfect medium for teaching early readers.  They’re also a wonderful incentive to read alone because they’re so difficult to read aloud without feeling somewhat awkward or doing a lot of voices. (I get embarrassed to read with too many silly voices.  Also, it’s easy to lose track of how you’re doing each voice.  Does anyone else have this problem?)

I really wish there were more series of comic book style early readers.  There are a few beautiful wordless picture books, like The Adventures of Polo by Regis Faller.  And, of course, there’s Mo Willems’s amazing Elephant and Piggie books, which are like very simplified comics.  However, the only other early readers I know of are the dreadful Phonics Comics, which are the sort of early readers that seem to assume children don’t deserve decent books.  The middle grades and YA markets are increasingly filling up with graphic novels.  Even the chapter books section is getting more, such as the Lunch Lady novels by Jarrett Krosoczka.  I can only hope that the trend is going to filter down into early readers and give us even more options.

I hate to judge a book by its cover, but I think this one pretty much sums up the quality of the text as well. Avoid.

3 thoughts on “Comics for Kids

  1. Thanks for warning me about Pony Tales… that is totally one Willow would grab for! I am loving your blog and working hard on keeping up on reading it! Thanks Farrar!

  2. I have the reading-in-voices problem, too. I like doing it, but it’s hard to keep track of which voice belongs to which character. It’s also hard coming up with enough distinctive voices. Mainly I use pitch. I suppose if I threw in accents and speed etc. I could do better, but would my readee understand less?

  3. You’re right, the only way to make sense of reading a comic out loud is voices, which is exhausting. And I totally have the problem of losing track of my voices, too. 3 is my max without getting confused.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s