A Load of Malarkey

Warning: rant ahead.

It looks so innocuous, doesn’t it? Even positive. But I find this Venn diagram and most of the others I see circulated on social media like it to be a harmful thing. It’s not the way I want to frame my life and definitely not a trap I want my kids to fall into.

Some version of this diagram – sometimes with only three circles, often with different graphic design – comes around every month or two on my various feeds, shared by people whose ideas I usually think are pretty positive and open-minded. It seems like a great idea. You’re asking people to look at their lives and think about how to bring different pieces together, to find meaning, to help others, to think about what they do well. It sounds great.

The problem is that this graph is not achievable for a huge number of people. Getting paid to do something is outside your control to a large extent. Your passion may be something that simply isn’t marketable or easily monetized. And your gifts may not include monetizing your passions. In fact, monetizing one’s passions has a cost for that passion for many people, a cost that some people are uncomfortable paying. So where are you stuck then? Supposedly without a purpose.

It surprises me that I’ve seen so many homeschool moms share this graph because we all have a calling to educate our children. No one is willing to pay us for it, yet we persist. According to this, we have no purpose in our lives. In fact, we’re not even allowed to call education our vocation because according to the Venn diagram, that requires money.

I find an incredible amount of purpose in my life teaching my kids. At this moment, while I do have other things in my life, teaching my children is my driving force. It’s the thing I do all day, the thing that brings me meaning and fulfillment.

Of course, those “other things” are important too. I write, I see friends, I read, I make art. Those things are also an important piece of my purpose and fulfillment in life.

I think this graph is a trap that we build for people in our society. We tell each other that the only path to meaningful lives is to find a career that will do everything for us, a career that we love, that gives us purpose and a comfortable life. We tell ourselves that unless we are paid in money for something, that is has no value. Since others are who pays us, we allow others to determine the value of our work on every level. For a few people, life does work out that way. But for most people I know, they may like their jobs and even find some level of purpose in them, but it’s through their creating unpaid art, coaching their kids’ sports team, passionately discussing books with friends, volunteering at a local charity, sustaining their church or other such work that they actually find a huge part of their fulfillment. The job is what lets them live comfortably and may even be enjoyable work, but it isn’t what brings everyone purpose. That’s the “other things.” And this graph devalues them. It says they’re not important to the real picture. The graph says that shouldn’t be the goal. It’s settling for something lesser.

You see, I’ve also seen people struggle with this and feel like they can’t be happy unless their job is what brings them happiness. It’s looking for paid work to bring us all the answers. Sometimes it can, but sometimes the answers are in unpaid work, family, community, or hobbies. We make it harder for people to find that sense of purpose when we tell them that everything must come together and they should get paid for it. Money is important. There’s no getting around that. If you don’t have enough money to provide basic food and shelter, then you’re never going to have the level of happiness that you need. But if you can achieve that level of basic financial security, I think it’s possible to find purpose in your life and a job doesn’t have to be the source of that purpose.

So I say if being a lawyer is what brings you purpose, then great. if playing role playing games is what brings you purpose, that’s great too. If volunteering at a food bank is what brings you purpose that’s great. If baking fabulous cakes for everyone’s birthday is what brings you purpose, don’t feel like you have to open your own bakery or it isn’t really purpose. If teaching your children is what brings you purpose, then that is purpose, even if no one is paying you. If you get purpose from a bunch of different, unrelated things, that’s great too. Your job doesn’t have to do everything for you.

I want my kids to grow up knowing this. Knowing that if they’re out of work for a year or stuck in a job they dislike but can’t leave for awhile when they grow up, it doesn’t mean they can’t look for fulfillment and meaning in other places. It doesn’t have to mean they have no purpose. If they choose to do a job mostly for the money, it doesn’t mean they aren’t allowed to look for meaning through arts or writing or dance or acting. I want them to know that giving away your time can be more fulfilling and purpose filled than a paying job. And that the world needs people who make money and carefully give it away. I want them to see that this is only one model for living a happy live. It’s not the only model and certainly not the only way to find purpose.


9 thoughts on “A Load of Malarkey

  1. Thanks for posting this. I’ve missed any recent posts about this but I agree with you completely. I think it’s such an enormous amount of misguided pressure that *sounds* like such positive advice, and I have seen its toll in my family. What’s wrong with just enjoying the things you like for fun, when you’re not at work, and having a nice, steady career? There also seems to be some thought that you should pick your career *entirely* without consideration for money, as if it is some irrelevant factor if you have enough money to subsist on or that we are all backed by a family fortune that can pay for all of this. It is especially ironic to see this coming from homeschooling moms, but maybe it’s part of the fantasy that we can survive on income from blog advertising and somehow monetize that. But monetizing things is not “the” answer.

    1. So agreed. I wish people had helped me understand better how to think about money when I was younger. I felt like it was either a goal of it’s own for maniacal businessmen or something that would just happen if you only could manage to monetize your passions. Um, nope.

    2. I totally agree. I have several passions that I pursue because I *want* to. I’ve even had opportunity to monetize these passions and I’ve turned them down EVERY time. It’s not fun if I have to do it to get paid!

      And there’s nothing wrong with teaching our children the practicalities of life…things like paying bills and not taking out thousands in student loans to get a degree in something that won’t pay the bills. Enjoy your passions! But think about how life is going to play out and teach your kids to consider the future wisely.

  2. I enjoyed this post too, though with some reservation. Reservation because this Venn Diagram IS what is pushed in public school, where I was educated, and it’s very hard to push that conditioning away. I think your thoughts extend too to the pressure placed on kids to go to college – for anything, so long as they go. And where does that land many of us? With thousands of dollars of debt and still unable to enter our choice field because there are no jobs, a lot of competition, or we need more education. I do not at all object to college, I hope my kids feel inspired to go, yet, like this diagram, I think it’s not all there is, and the universal push to attend implies that a job is what is important and not the rest of your life.
    Good thoughts.

  3. Thanks for your rant. A friend of mine posted this the other day and I thought about going into a rant on his Facebook post, but realized he didn’t deserve that. I settled for a cynical “Good luck with that.” I remember when I first got out of college I took a job that I really felt was pointless. It wasn’t immoral, but I knew the world would get on just fine if no one did the job I was doing. I had just been taking classes from a guy who wrote a book on the importance of “vocation” and the value of meaningful work in life. I realized that in many ways the guy was well off the mark, because most of humanity around the world didn’t even have the option to think about the sorts of things he said were essential. Rather than looking for fulfilling work it is often necessary to find fulfillment in whatever work allows you to live out the rest of your life as your conscience dictates.

  4. I have discussed this with my kids. I have told them it is great if they have passions and there is no reason that they shouldn’t pursue or do them but that didn’t mean that it would necessarily be their job and they get paid for it. It might simply be a hobby. I mean seriously if we ALL followed our passions who’d collect rubbish, clean toilets etc. (apologies if this was anyones passion)?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s